The Science Behind What Shoppers Buy: 5 Retail Display Secrets Worth Testing
What consumer-behavior research reveals about shelf placement, shopping habits, and simple changes that could improve your store's sales.
Walk into almost any retail store, and you'll see products carefully arranged on shelves. Some are placed at eye level, others near the checkout, and some are grouped with related products.
But have you ever wondered whether those decisions actually influence what customers buy?
Researchers have spent years studying how shoppers move through stores, where their eyes naturally travel, and what makes them notice one product instead of another.
Some findings confirm what experienced retailers already know. Others challenge traditional merchandising advice.
Here are five research-backed discoveries worth testing in your own store.
1. Shoppers Really Do Pay More Attention to Their Right
Here's something you may not know.
A 2021 study published in the Journal of Marketing Research used wearable eye-tracking technology to examine how customers looked at products while walking through grocery aisles.
The researchers discovered that shoppers paid more attention to products on their right side as they traveled down an aisle.
Think about what that could mean for your store.
If customers typically enter an aisle from one direction, the products on their right may receive more visual attention than products on their left.
That doesn't automatically mean more purchases. But customers generally need to notice a product before they can consider buying it.
Try this in your store:
Identify an aisle where most customers travel in the same direction.
Place a featured BBQ seasoning or injection on the right side of that shopping path.
Track its sales for two weeks, then compare results with its previous location.
The important detail is the customer's direction of travel—not simply the right side of your store.
Research: Chen, Burke, Hui & Leykin (2021), Understanding Lateral and Vertical Biases in Consumer Attention.
2. Eye Level Might Not Be the Best Selling Level
You've probably heard the expression, "Eye level is buy level."
But research suggests the story is more complicated.
The same 2021 eye-tracking study found that the shelf position attracting the greatest visual attention was approximately 14.7 inches below shoppers' eye level.
That's closer to chest height for many adults.
This doesn't mean every product should be moved down a shelf. Other studies have found advantages for higher shelf positions, and shoppers differ in height and shopping behavior.
What it does suggest is that retailers shouldn't automatically assume the highest-value shelf position is directly at eye level.
Try this in your store:
Choose a product that sells consistently but isn't one of your strongest performers.
Move it from a high or low shelf to approximately chest height.
Keep the price, signage, and number of visible packages the same.
Compare unit sales over similar periods.
You might discover that a small shelf adjustment makes a meaningful difference.
Research: Chen, Burke, Hui & Leykin (2021), Journal of Marketing Research.
3. Grouping Products by What Customers Want to Cook Can Increase Purchases
This finding may be especially useful for BBQ retailers.
In a study published in the Journal of Marketing Research in 2019, researchers examined what happened when stores organized complementary products around how customers use them.
Instead of grouping products primarily by product type, they arranged items according to a shared purpose.
In one field experiment, the researchers found that, 20 weeks after the change, average weekly purchases were 17.18% higher in item count than the model estimated would have occurred without the change.
Average weekly customer spending was also 9.03% higher than the estimated no-change scenario.
Those results came from the stores studied, not from BBQ departments, and shouldn't be treated as a guaranteed sales increase.
But the underlying idea is worth exploring.
Consider two ways to organize BBQ merchandise.
Traditional product organization:
All injections together
All seasonings together
All sauces together
All cooking tools together
Cooking-purpose organization:
Smoking a brisket: injection, rub, butcher paper, and trimming tools
Cooking ribs: seasoning, glaze, and sauce
Preparing pulled pork: pork injection, rub, and finishing sauce
Grilling dinner: everyday seasoning and grilling oil
The second approach helps customers discover products they might need for the same cooking project.
You don't necessarily need to reorganize your entire department.
Try this in your store:
Create one small display labeled "Everything for Your Next Brisket."
Include Butcher BBQ brisket injection, a brisket rub, butcher paper, and a relevant cooking tool.
Compare the number of items purchased per BBQ transaction before and after introducing the display.
Pay attention to whether customers begin purchasing more complementary products together.
Research: Sarantopoulos, Theotokis, Pramatari & Roggeveen (2019), The Impact of a Complement-Based Assortment Organization on Purchases.
4. A Simple Shelf Sign Can Change What Customers Notice
Shelf signs aren't just decorations.
A 2014 study published in the Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services examined how shoppers responded to in-store signage using eye-tracking experiments.
Researchers found that signage helped customers notice displayed products and influenced where they directed their attention.
Another study, published in 2015, combined eye-tracking research with actual retail sales data. It found that signage could increase attention and sales for the highlighted product.
However, the researchers also found that those gains could come partly at the expense of competing products.
In other words, a sign might help one product sell better without necessarily increasing total department sales.
That's an important distinction.
Try this in your store:
Choose a product that customers may not immediately understand, such as a meat injection.
Place a small educational sign nearby explaining what the product does and how it is used.
For example:
"Smoking a Brisket? Add Flavor and Moisture Before It Hits the Smoker."
Measure both the product's sales and the overall BBQ department's sales during the test.
Butcher BBQ offers promotional shelf signs and other retailer marketing materials to help our wholesale partners explain products to customers.
Research: Otterbring and colleagues (2014), Vision (im)possible? The Effects of In-Store Signage on Customers' Visual Attention; Clement, Aastrup & Forsberg (2015), Decisive Visual Saliency and Consumers' In-Store Decisions.
5. More Shelf Space Can Help a Product Get Noticed—But Attention Isn't Everything
Here's another interesting finding.
A 2009 study published in the Journal of Marketing examined how the number of visible product facings influenced shoppers' attention and product evaluations.
Researchers found that increasing the number of facings could influence how shoppers evaluated a brand, largely because the additional shelf presence attracted more visual attention.
But the study also cautioned that attention alone doesn't always translate into better sales.
That means filling a shelf with extra jars of a slow-moving product isn't automatically a winning strategy.
A larger display might get noticed, but it also uses valuable space that could be occupied by something customers actually want.
Try this in your store:
Choose a popular BBQ product that already has reliable sales.
Increase its visible facings from two to four, without changing its price or shelf location.
Track weekly unit sales.
Then compare whether the additional shelf space generated enough sales to justify keeping it.
The objective isn't to give every product more room. It's to learn which products deserve more visibility.
Research: Chandon, Hutchinson, Bradlow & Young (2009), Does In-Store Marketing Work?
The 14-Day Retail Display Challenge
You don't need an expensive store remodel to put these findings to work.
Start with one product, one display, and one measurable change.
Days 1–7: Establish Your Starting Point
Choose a BBQ product or small group of products.
Record:
Units sold
Total sales dollars
Number of transactions containing the selected products
Average number of BBQ items per transaction, if your register provides that information
Avoid making unrelated changes to the display, price, or promotion during the test.
Days 8–14: Change One Thing
Choose one experiment:
Move the product to the right side of a commonly traveled aisle.
Change its shelf height.
Group it with complementary BBQ products.
Add an educational shelf sign.
Increase its visible shelf facings.
Track the same measurements for another seven days.
Compare Your Results
Did unit sales increase?
Did customers purchase more products together?
Did the change increase total BBQ department sales, or simply shift purchases from one product to another?
A single week can be influenced by weather, promotions, holidays, and customer traffic. For more reliable results, repeat promising tests over several comparable weeks.
Even if the experiment doesn't produce an improvement, you've learned something valuable about your customers.
Small Changes. Better Information. Smarter Decisions.
Every retail store is different.
A hardware store, butcher shop, grocery store, and specialty BBQ retailer may attract different customers with different shopping habits.
That's why the most valuable merchandising strategy isn't necessarily copying what another retailer does.
It's understanding what works in your own store.
Research gives us ideas worth testing. Your sales results tell you which ideas deserve a permanent place on your shelves.
At Butcher BBQ, we believe helping our wholesale partners succeed means providing more than great BBQ products.
It means sharing useful information, practical merchandising ideas, and marketing resources that help you make better retail decisions.
Your next great sales improvement might be sitting on the wrong shelf right now.
Research Sources
Chen, M., Burke, R. R., Hui, S. K., & Leykin, A. (2021). Understanding Lateral and Vertical Biases in Consumer Attention: An In-Store Ambulatory Eye-Tracking Study. Journal of Marketing Research. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022243721998375
Sarantopoulos, P., Theotokis, A., Pramatari, K., & Roggeveen, A. L. (2019). The Impact of a Complement-Based Assortment Organization on Purchases. Journal of Marketing Research. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022243718823698
Otterbring, T., Wästlund, E., Gustafsson, A., & Shams, P. (2014). Vision (im)possible? The Effects of In-Store Signage on Customers' Visual Attention. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jretconser.2014.05.002
Clement, J., Aastrup, J., & Forsberg, S. C. (2015). Decisive Visual Saliency and Consumers' In-Store Decisions. Journal of Retailing and Consumer Services. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jretconser.2014.09.002
Chandon, P., Hutchinson, J. W., Bradlow, E. T., & Young, S. H. (2009). Does In-Store Marketing Work? Effects of the Number and Position of Shelf Facings on Brand Attention and Evaluation at the Point of Purchase. Journal of Marketing. https://doi.org/10.1509/jmkg.73.6.1




Comments